
BRONZE BUTLER
Also known as:REDBALDKNIGHT · Tick
Overview
BRONZE BUTLER is a cyber espionage group with likely Chinese origins that has been active since at least 2008. The group primarily targets Japanese organizations, particularly those in government, biotechnology, electronics manufacturing, and industrial chemistry.
Naming & attribution
BRONZE BUTLER is tracked under 3 names across the industry. It uses 40 documented ATT&CK techniques — more than 74% of the 174 groups tracked here. Activity attributed since at least 2008.
| Name | First reported by |
|---|---|
| REDBALDKNIGHT | Chen, J. and Hsieh, M |
| Tick | Chen, J. and Hsieh, M |
| BRONZE BUTLER | Chen, J. and Hsieh, M |
Distinctive techniques
Techniques this group uses that are rare across the other 173 tracked groups — these carry more signal than the near-universal ones.
T1053.002At — used by 3 of 174 groupsT1550.003Pass the Ticket — used by 3 of 174 groups
Closest groups by technique overlap
Computed from shared ATT&CK techniques. Overlap is not attribution — distinct actors converge on the same tradecraft — but a high share is a useful pivot.
Targets
Diplomacy · Engineering · Industrial · Infrastructure · Manufacturing · Media · Political party · Private sector
Regions
China · Japan · Russian Federation · South Korea
Capabilities
- Exploitation of public-facing / client applications — ATT&CK T1203
- Custom malware/implant development — ATT&CK: 7 attributed custom malware families
TTPs — 40 techniques across 12 tactics
Resource Development
T1588.002Tool
Initial Access
T1189Drive-by CompromiseT1566.001Spearphishing Attachment
Execution
T1053.002AtT1053.005Scheduled TaskT1059.001PowerShellT1059.003Windows Command ShellT1059.005Visual BasicT1059.006PythonT1203Exploitation for Client ExecutionT1204.002Malicious File
Persistence
T1547.001Registry Run Keys / Startup Folder
Privilege Escalation
T1548.002Bypass User Account Control
Stealth
T1027.001Binary PaddingT1027.003SteganographyT1036MasqueradingT1036.002Right-to-Left OverrideT1036.005Match Legitimate Resource Name or LocationT1070.004File DeletionT1140Deobfuscate/Decode Files or InformationT1574.001DLL
Defense Impairment
Credential Access
T1003.001LSASS Memory
Discovery
T1007System Service DiscoveryT1018Remote System DiscoveryT1083File and Directory DiscoveryT1087.002Domain AccountT1124System Time DiscoveryT1518Software Discovery
Lateral Movement
T1080Taint Shared ContentT1550.003Pass the Ticket
Collection
T1005Data from Local SystemT1039Data from Network Shared DriveT1113Screen CaptureT1560.001Archive via Utility
Command and Control
T1071.001Web ProtocolsT1102.001Dead Drop ResolverT1105Ingress Tool TransferT1132.001Standard EncodingT1573.001Symmetric Cryptography
Tools & malware (14)
Mimikatz · build_downer · cmd · ABK · at · BBK · schtasks · down_new · Daserf · Net · ShadowPad · Windows Credential Editor · gsecdump · Avenger
Reporting (3)
- Operation ENDTRADE: TICK’s Multi-Stage Backdoors for Attacking Industries and Stealing Classified Data — Chen, J. et al
- REDBALDKNIGHT/BRONZE BUTLER’s Daserf Backdoor Now Using Steganography — Chen, J. and Hsieh, M
- BRONZE BUTLER Targets Japanese Enterprises — Counter Threat Unit Research Team